Zed Maps. Design process.

164 decisions, 225 screens and readings from 35 photographs across 10 stations stand behind these four parts. Each part shows a few of them.

01 Modelling

Design process

The model was looked up, not drawn from memory. Colours come from data and photographs, sizes carry their source, and each part was checked against the real place.

A · Colour

From the official colours to one station

  1. Line colours from the open data. The values copied all over the web are wrong for every line. The official set is used, on route bullets only.
  2. Signs as they are. Black, white type, the line's bullet: the same sign at every station.
  3. One accent per station. A blue column at 28 St, a maroon one at 34 St–Herald Sq: taken from the real station, and the only colour that changes.
  4. The line's colour on the track. A faint band between the rails carries the platform sign's own words and the way the trains run.
  5. Ten stations, one finding. Tile, floor, steel and signs are the same everywhere. Six structure colours serve them all.
Six structure colours, two for safety and street, one accent per station
Step 3 · the accent is the only thing that changes: five stations, five tablets
Step 2 · the exit sign, as on the platform
Step 4 · direction on the track bed, in the colour of the line: yellow, purple, red
Colour readings from reference photographs (Wikimedia Commons). No photograph is reproduced; readings fix the hue, design sets the brightness
B · Kit

The standard each element is built to

Every element is modelled once, on its own, before it enters a station: 28 in the station kit. Each size carries where it came from and how far it can be trusted, so a guess is never shown as a fact.

Train, head car
18.35 × 2.98 m
Encyclopaedia
Between two cars
footplate, chains, barriers
Photographs
Open-gangway train
interior continuous
Encyclopaedia
Turnstile
aisle 0.42 m, 0.56 m above
Procurement document
Stair, tiled walls
tile 108 mm, riser 0.18 m
Counted from photographs
Stair, steel
riser 0.18 m
Ordinary practice
Escalator, glass sides
one model, every station
Ordinary practice
Column with station sign
0.40 m face, 4.57 m apart
Measured from photographs, ±15%
C · Checked on the real place

The model corrected, round after round

28 St. Street data showed stairs that ended inside buildings; street imagery showed two signal arms where one had been drawn. The corners were rebuilt as whole blocks.

Hudson Yards, the entrance canopy. Five readings of the same object: a first shell, the size calibrated, the supports re-examined, the Y-shaped supports stood upright, the rim made regular.

Before · notched sidewalks
After · whole blocks
1 · first shell
2 · size calibrated
3 · supports re-examined
4 · Y supports upright
5 · rim made regular, as it stands
D · Designed curves

A park, in a cartographer's six steps

  1. Sources and their weight. An aerial view fixes the shape; the designer's plan explains it. Neither is traced.
  2. Generalisation. At this scale a paving band is kept whole; single stones are not drawn.
  3. Geometry. One leading curve, the others follow it. Smoothing runs along a line only, so a sharp cut stays sharp.
  4. Symbols. Three pavings are told apart by pattern, not by a new colour.
  5. Overlay check. The model is laid back over the aerial view, block by block.
  6. Display by scale. What is drawn depends on distance: the table below.
Step 2–3 · complete bands, led by one curve
Step 4 · three pavings by pattern
Step 5 · the fountains as built
Step 6 · one landmark at three distances
Far · the cityMiddle · a few blocksNear · within about 150 m
Groundthe map's plain groundthe same; parks as flat greenpaving with joints, kerbs, crossings
Landmarksmass, crown, accentfloor lines, setbacksrails, doors, deck detail
Stationentrances as pointsvolumes, platforms, named entranceseverything
Street furniturenonetrees as soft masses in parkslamps, signals, benches, beds
Routea linea line with its stepsa ribbon with chevrons

02 Page design

Design process

Every visual rule has a reason that can be shown: what is drawn exactly and what is not, how the route reads on any ground, and what light and dark really change.

A · Detail

Three levels of drawing

What is on the route is drawn exactly and in solid colour: the train door, the turnstiles, the stairs, the signs. What stands beside the route is simplified and neutral. The street round the station is translucent context.

On the route: exact
Beside the route: plain
The street: translucent masses
B · Route

The edge of the route line

A white outline was the first idea. Reading pixels from two web maps showed what they do instead: the edge is the same hue as the fill, darker on bright ground and lighter on dark ground. One fill, two edges.

Web map A, light, main routefill ~#4014F0 · edge ~#11007E
Web map A, light, alternatefill ~#BCCDFF · edge ~#3E3EB8
Web map B, lightfill ~#4490FF · edge ~#2558C2
Web map B, darkfill ~#2C70F0 · edge ~#5A90F0
Above: read from screenshots of two web maps. Below: adopted here.
Adopted, on bright groundfill #2F80FF · edge #1A4FB8
Adopted, on dark groundfill #2F80FF · edge #7FB0FF
C · Light and dark

What dark mode really switches

The interface theme and the light of the scene are two separate things. Materials never change. Indoors a dark interface only dims the light to 85%; night exists outdoors and follows the hour in New York.

Three dimming levels side by side; 85% chosen
Night exists outdoors: the deck, the lit entrance, the street
D · Indoors to outdoors

One route, an edge that changes on the way out

In a dark interface the station stays lit, so the route keeps its dark edge there. On the stair to the street the edge blends, and under the night sky it is the light one. The fill never changes; the change of edge tells the walker where indoors ends.

A night trip in five zones: station, stair, street, door, landmark
On the stair: before the rule, and after
E · Two layouts

One page, upright and wide

The same page at two sizes, without the phone round it. Upright and narrow, the trip is a sheet at the bottom, low by default so the route stays in view. Wide, the same trip is a card at the side and the map takes the rest. Nothing is hidden in either; the controls keep to the right edge in both.

Upright · 466 × 678 · plan
Wide · 951 × 669 · plan
Upright · walk
Wide · walk

03 Interaction

Design process

The map changes as the task does. Under that sits ordinary craft: a short scale of sizes, the habits people already have, and a layout that survives a folding screen.

A · Anatomy

The trip card, measured

One card carries the whole trip. Its sizes come from one short scale, so every gap, corner and line of type can be named. The dashed lines are the edges its parts share: one left edge, one column for the values, one right edge, and rows of one height.

content edge · 20 invalues · one columncontent edge · 20 inCard · radius 20 · padding 20Title · 20 / 700Close · 36 round, compactRow · body 15 · label 12Answer · radius 12 · padding 12 16Time · 28 / 700Length · 13, mutedAdvice · 12 · padding 8 12Main action · height 44 · radius 12Gap between buttons · 8
Spacing4 · 8 · 12 · 16 · 20 · 242 only for hairlines
Radius20 card · 12 control · full for pills
Type11 · 12 · 13 · 15 · 17 · 20 · 28
Control height36 compact · 44 standard44 is the smallest target a finger hits surely
Shadowtwo levelscard, and control
Alignment3 edges · rows of 46dashed, in red
B · Habits

Asking less, in the order people expect

The first card asked three questions. The second follows what riders already know from every map: where from, where to, and one button to turn the trip round.

BeforeNow
Train, position, exit: three questionsFrom and To, with a button that turns the trip round
"Which car are you in?"Not asked. The walk starts mid-train; where to ride next time is one line of advice
One fixed exit for each destination+ Add a place on the way: choose the exit, the route, time and distance redraw
"Uptown platform", "east side"The platform sign's own words: "Uptown & Queens"
28 St
Hudson Yards
C · Adaptation

Closed and open: what moves, what stays

Measured at the phone's own sizes and shown on its own shape: closed, the hinge side is square and the outer side round (the front camera is left out of the drawing). Closed, the plan is a sheet 231 points high of 678, a third of the screen, and Start is always in view. Open, it is a card 380 wide at the side. The controls keep to the right edge in both, where a thumb reaches.

Closed · 466 × 678
sheet at the bottom

Open · 951 × 669
card at the side

D · States

The map changes as the task does

Four states, one map. Each shows only what its task needs.

01 ExploreWhere to?All of Manhattan, flat. Landmarks and stations as points.
02 PlaceWhere inside?The landmark stands up in 3D; its entrances are named.
03 PlanWhich exit, which door?The place cut open, the whole trip laid out, time and length.
04 WalkWhat do I see next?First person, level by level, one step at a time.
03 Plan
04 Walk
E · Road

Where it goes next

V111 landmarksRoutes from every subway entrance, each step with its evidence.
V2 · nowOne route, door to deckStation, street and building joined; the kit; the walk.

04 What was overturned

Design process

Six first answers that did not survive a check. Each was replaced because of evidence, or because a review asked a question the first answer could not meet.

The route line's edge

Review
First answer
Now

A white outline was drawn first. Pixel readings of two web maps showed an edge of the same hue: darker on bright ground, lighter on dark.

What dark mode darkens

Review
First answer
Now

The first dark draft turned white tile nearly black. A lit station does not go dark because a phone does: materials stay, the light dims to 85%.

Direction on the track

Review
First answer
Now

Arrows between the rails read as the arrows painted on a road. Now a faint band in the line's colour carries the platform sign's own words and three chevrons.

Columns on the platform

Evidence
First answer
Now

A written source said the platform had no columns. Photographs showed a row of blue ones, each with a station sign.

The plan on a closed folding phone

Evidence
First answer
Now

At the size it was first tried the plan looked fine. At the phone's real size it covered 64% of the screen and hid Start. It became a sheet of two heights.

One edge for the whole route

Review
First answer
Now

One edge everywhere was wrong at night: the station stays lit, the street does not. The edge now changes on the stair out, and the fill never does.